Showing posts with label GOP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label GOP. Show all posts

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Jindal's Hack Attacks


Alan Levine was billed as the "Department of Health and Hospitals Secretary" when he appeared at the Baton Rouge Press Club on Monday. But as anyone who caught his presentation (PDF) on the impact of healthcare reform on Louisiana immediately grasped, the cabinet secretary title is a cover for Levine's true role as Jindal's most ardent partisan hack.

From attacking healthcare reform to barring DHH employees from talking to legislators about policy to calling for investigations to try to stifle opposition to privatization, Alan Levine is the tip of the spear on the governor's effort to use healthcare policy to shrink state government and give more power (and money) to private contractors.

Levine is continuing the work that Jindal started as Mike Foster's DHH secretary just over a decade ago. The difference is that Levine actually knows something about healthcare policy (if Jindal knows anything about it, he learned it after he left DHH) and has not (at least not yet) displayed the kind of unbridled political ambition that Jindal personifies.

Still, Levine came to the job after finding his place in Florida politics in Jeb Bush's second administration. He came to Louisiana after taking over a struggling hospital system for Bush, privatized much of it (some of it using no-bid contracts) and rode that success to his job with Jindal.

Man On A Mission

Levine came to Louisiana in 2008 on a mission. That mission was to radically restructure the delivery of healthcare in Louisiana in a way that would help propel Jindal's Republican political ambitions.

First on the agenda was a complete makeover of Medicaid, the jointly funded healthcare program that provides care to women, children and the disabled. Levine had run a pilot program in Florida that set up a managed care approach to running Medicaid there. The idea was to limit spending by restricting access to care. The restriction would come through the management of care by third-party entities who had a similar role in the scheme to that of HMOs. There was a fixed pool of money. The managed care provider would negotiate a package deal with providers to provide care for Medicaid patients. The managed care provider would get paid out of the existing pool of funds.

It is classic conservative Republican approach to policy: make the dollars go further by cutting back on the amount of services delivered and make some company rich in the process.

Levine hit the ground running in Louisiana, but there were complications with the calendar. Jindal and Levine wanted to get a Medicaid waiver approved by the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) while the Bush administration was still in office. This should not have been an issue seeing as Jindal had served in that administration and Levine had served in the administration of the President's brother who was the governor of Florida.

There were complications.

The first factor was that the move could not begin until the new state budget for Fiscal Year 2008-2009 was in place. Louisiana fiscal years begin on July 1. It took Levine a couple of months to organize an advisory committee whose purpose was ostensibly to provide input on the development of a Medicaid waiver request.

The panel was barely in place when the first of what has become a seemingly unending series of Medicaid budget shortfalls was discovered in late September of 2008. Shortly after that happened, Levine christened his Medicaid waiver "Louisiana Health First" and the generally genial discussions with the so-called advisory panel continued.

Things blew up when Jindal and Levine announced the plan fully-formed in November 2008 and committed to filing with with CMS in the waning days of the Bush administration. Members of the advisory committee went public with criticism of Levine for a lack of transparency in the process they were allegedly supposed to be participants in. It certainly appeared to the members of that group that they had been used by Levine to provide a patina of legitimacy to a plan that Levine had developed without their input or knowledge.

It was two days before Christmas, 2008, before Levine got his waiver request to CMS — the Legislature had to sign off on it and there were questions. By this time, all the DC Bushies were either too busy packing or had already left the nation's capital seeking new opportunities in what was no longer a Republican town.

Louisiana Health First came to naught, though it did poison Levine's credibility among Medicaid providers — a distrust that informs his relations with them today.

Privatization

The first big challenge for the Jindal administration on the privatization front was the question of what to do with Big Charity Hospital in New Orleans, which had been rendered useless by the post-Katrina flooding.

Governor Kathleen Blanco had somehow convinced a recalcitrant Louisiana Legislature to approve planning dollars for three new LSU hospitals in the wake of the storms of 2005 — Big Charity, Earl K. Long Medical Center in Baton Rouge, and Huey P. Long Medical Center in Pineville.

The initial impulse of the administration was to scrap all three hospitals, but the pressure to build a new hospital in New Orleans was too important to the post-Katrina recovery narrative for Jindal to ignore. Combined with a commitment from the Veterans Administration to build a new hospital in New Orleans, the project constitutes a nearly $2 billion investment in post-Katrina New Orleans.

Levine became the point man on what became very clearly a quid pro quo between the administration and LSU. The deal came down to this: LSU could get a hospital in New Orleans but it could not get a hospital in Baton Rouge, too. Sort of a "nice hospital you've got there, LSU. It would be a shame if anything happened to it." The new Pineville hospital was dead on arrival.

In the dance that ensued, LSU ended up negotiating a deal with Our Lady of the Lake Regional Medical Center thereby enabling the closure of Earl K. Long. Some of the capacity served by that hospital will be replaced by a large outpatient clinic near Earl K. Long. Our Lady of the Lake agreed to take some of the Medicaid patient load (at a higher-than-average reimbursement rate) and to become home for LSU's medical training program in Baton Rouge. They'll also get a Tier 1 trauma center, courtesy of the state.

Cerise told the Times-Picayune after the deal was struck that the cost of shifting care from Earl K. Long to OLOL will actually drive up Medicaid costs in the Baton Rouge area. So, this example shows that cost savings is not the intent of the Jindal/Levine privatization effort. Instead, the goal is to dismantle public healthcare infrastructure ranging from public hospitals in the LSU hospital system to the state's three mental health hospitals in Mandeville, Pineville and Jackson.

This clearly is privatization for privatization's sake. It will have two immediate impacts. First, it will remove hundreds (ultimately thousands if carried to its end) of workers from the state payroll. Second, it will create lucrative contracting opportunities for private sector firms who move in to operate the remaining operations which is the plan for the mental health hospitals.

The question of the quality of care given to patients was raised in one legislative hearing by a family member of a resident in one of the state mental health institutions. It is apparently not relevant to Jindal and Levine as it is not quantifiable as a budget item.

Jackson: A Deal Too Far

Levine's effort to privatize the state's mental health hospitals has sparked a surprising bi-partisan rebellion in the Legislature against the move. The plan to privatize the East Louisiana State Hospital at Jackson was apparently the deal too far.

East, as it is known, is located in East Feliciana Parish. The move to privatize jeopardizes hundreds of jobs in that rural parish and that brought employees and the business community together in opposition to the plan. It led to a confrontation in the Legislature where the normally Jindal-friendly House voted to require legislative oversight of the privatization process.

Levine, apparently seeking to crush the rebellion at ground zero, called on the inspector general to review employment records at the three facilities — East, Central Louisiana State Hospital in Pineville and Southeast Louisiana Hospital at Mandeville — to check what he suggested were abuses of the family leave policies at the facilities.

Attacking Healthcare Reform

Jindal and Levine were early critics of President Obama's attempts to reform the nation's healthcare delivery system, and they have not relented since 2009.

Levine was called to Washington by congressional Republicans to deliver highly partisan attacks on the Democratic initiative dating to its infancy. No matter the shape of the reform at any given time during the arduous legislative journey to becoming law, Levine could be counted on to take up the Republican talking points against the plan.

Once the bill became law in April, Levine became the in-state point man of Republican efforts to fight the implementation of the law.

Levine testified before the Louisiana House Insurance Committee on April 20 in support of Representative Kirk Talbot's constitutional amendment to have the state nullify the provisions of the Affordable Care Act. Levine, like Talbot, put the fight within the context of states' rights.

Well, any excuse would do, wouldn't it.

In late May, when the non-partisan Kaiser Family Foundation published a state-by-state assessment of the impact of the Affordable Care Act on extending coverage to low-wage individuals and families, Levine lashed out with a partisan harangue that focused only on the cost side of the law and the analysis. Nowhere in his response could Levine bring himself to acknowledge any benefit being derived —economic, community, social or otherwise — that would result from extending healthcare coverage to a broad swath of Louisiana's large number of uninsured residents.

That inability to acknowledge any positive aspect in a policy or program being opposed is the trademark of an ideologue.

And it was Levine the ideologue who took the podium at the Baton Rouge Press Club on Monday and delivered a presentation that is so blatantly political that it raises questions regarding how public funding can be used to produce such a clearly political document (PDF).

Lies, Damned Lies, and Levine's Statistics

Like Jindal, the only thing that has value in Levine's view of healthcare is money. If a program costs dollars, then it must be bad.

How else can one assess a 32-page presentation on a piece of landmark social legislation that never mentions any social benefit but focuses exclusively on the cost of the program — and inflates those costs to cast the legislation in the worst possible light?

Levine's intent is to show as large dollar costs to the state as he can possibly imagine. He projects 13 years out to come up with a projected increased cost to the state of $7 billion, and he has to use a premise of private sector employers dropping coverage for their workers and dumping them on the Medicaid rolls to get there.

Like Jindal, Levine assumes that state revenues will never increase again. Therefore, the prospect of the state actually having the revenue to pay for he increased costs that the program will actually bring are beyond his capability of imagining. One is left to assume that the idea of state revenues increasing would be considered a nightmare scenario in the world of Jindal/Levine.

Levine completely ignores the reality that the current system of employer based healthcare is not sustainable without reform. The Affordable Care Act maintains private sector insurance, imposes some requirements on companies and requires individuals to buy coverage. It provides tax credits to businesses to provide coverage and it provides subsidies to individuals and families to enable them to afford coverage. It will improve access to care for nearly all Louisiana residents, which will go far to address our chronic disease problems. It will inject billions of dollars into the care provider community, putting hospitals, clinics and individual providers on better financial footing.

Levine cannot bring himself to mention — much less admit — any of this.

This kind of distorted take on healthcare reform could be expected from the kind of partisan hack that Levine clearly is. But, he should stop hiding behind his title as cabinet secretary in his pursuit of his partisan agenda. Alan Levine is a suitable political operative for Bobby Jindal, but he is abusing his office as secretary of the Department of Health and Hospitals at this critical juncture in our state's history.

Serving in that capacity involves a public trust. Levine's loyalty should be to his oath and to the public. It is clear that his loyalty is to Jindal and his ideology.

If he had any decency, he'd resign.

Again, if he had any decency.

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Democratic Louisiana: "It Started With Jindal's Stelly Flip"

This article is "The Big Blue One" from Volume 1, Number 1, of Democratic Louisiana, a Louisiana d2d project.

Repealing the income tax portion of The Stelly Plan was not on Bobby Jindal’s agenda when he became governor in 2008, but as sentiment in the House grew for repeal, the new governor moved to leap in front of the parade that championed the repeal.

Under the Stelly Plan, which was approved by state voters in 2002 while Mike Foster was governor, the state sales tax on food for home consumption and the sales tax on natural gas, electricity, and water for residential use was lowered on January 1, 2003, from 3.9 cents to 2 cents per dollar. Taxes on those items were then eliminated on July 1, 2003. To replace revenue lost through Stelly, individual income tax brackets were adjusted upward.

The plan was not popular with those in the top two state income tax brackets where individuals paid up to $500 more in taxes each year.

In the 2007 statewide elections, Jindal romped to a primary win over a fragmented gubernatorial field and Republicans picked up significant representation in both the state House and Senate.

During the 2008 regular session of the Legislature, Jindal first opposed the repeal of the income tax provisions of the Stelly plan because of the loss of revenue would be too steep (about $358 million per year). Sensing the political momentum and not wanting to disappoint his conservative backers, Jindal flipped on the issue and endorsed the repeal. With the new governor’s backing, repeal passed easily. And Louisiana was sent careening down the road towards a financial crisis.

It did not take long for trouble to appear.

In December of 2008, the state discovered that it had a projected budget deficit for the 2008-09 fiscal year that nearly matched the cost of the Stelly repeal, dollar for dollar: $341 million.

The repeal of the income tax portion of the Stelly Plan is a mistake that keeps on giving as it deprives the state of significant revenue each year. Viewed another way, counting the budget proposed by Jindal and now being considered by the Louisiana Legislature, the repeal of the income tax portion of the Stelly plan has cost state government more than $1 billion dollars in revenue it otherwise would have had to meet rising need.

The Jindal Way: Afflicting the Afflicted

What rising need? The Louisiana Budget Project (LBP), a non-partisan arm of the Louisiana Association of Nonprofit Organizations, monitors and reports on state government spending and how it affects the Louisiana’s low- to moderate-income families. In LBP's review of Jindal’s 2011 Executive Budget ("Louisiana's Fiscal Crisis"), the organization notes,
“between January 2005 and January 2010, families using food stamps increased 20 percent. Medicaid enrollments increased 13 percent from pre-Katrina levels. The number of enrolled students at four-year institutions increased 3 percent between 2004 and 2009, from 214,144 to 220,381. At community colleges, enrollment increased 37 percent during the same time period, from 50,920 to 69,940. The state’s unemployment rate increased from 5.4 percent in December of 2004 to 7.3 percent in December of 2009."
Yet, confronted with these growing demands, Jindal has steadfastly refused to take any step to increase state revenues. Why? Because agreeing to increase taxes or fees would damage his national prospects among conservative Republicans whom he has courted assiduously since his election.

Jindal’s resistance to raising taxes or seeking other ways to raise revenue combined with the fact that healthcare and higher education are the only areas of the state budget not constitutionally protected from cuts has produced a budget balancing approach best summed up as “comforting the comfortable and afflicting the afflicted.”

Jindal’s calculation appears to be that he can build campaign for president (“The Louisiana Way” branding of his budget approach and the upcoming book some one wrote for him) on the backs of Medicaid recipients and providers and those in higher education.

Had the status quo held that might have been possible. But, as everyone knows, Louisiana’s economy has been floating on a sea of federal disaster dollars since the storms of 2005 (with more injected after the storms of 2008). That money is beginning to taper off. The LBP says federal dollars accounted for more than half of the state’s budget in 2009-10, and that will drop to 45% in the current budget.

And, with Jindal’s Republican colleagues in the Congress fighting to stop even the extension of unemployment benefits, the likelihood of additional federal economic recovery dollars is uncertain at best. The potential loss of those dollars is what sparks the talk of Louisiana’s budget going “over a cliff” next year.

That has forced Jindal to try to deny the undeniable (the state needs more revenue) by attempting shift program costs onto local governments, particularly local public school systems.

Jindal’s Blind Spot: Services Are Delivered By and Go To People

But, behind every number in a state budget is a human story. Dating back to his days when he was wrecking the public health network as Mike Foster’s secretary of the Department of Health and Hospitals, the evidence is that Bobby Jindal has never understood this basic fact.

And here is where Jindal’s anti-tax fanaticism is inflicting its greatest toll on the state.

Jindal’s budget cuts, particularly in Medicaid, reduce access to care for the poorest among us. Medicaid provides access to care for children, pregnant women and the disabled. Medicaid is a huge program in our state and Jindal and legislators have found making cuts there relatively easy because of the size of the program. Medicaid is an insurance program. It does not give money to patients, it pays for patient care by paying providers — doctors, nurses, hospitals — for that care. The reason providers are turning away Medicaid patients is that the state of Louisiana keeps cutting the amount of money they will pay those providers to give that care.

So, Medicaid budget cuts impact not just the poor and the disabled, they also impact the healthcare provider community. The Louisiana Hospital Association (LHA) said Jindal’s proposed budget 2009 cuts would have cost nearly 2,000 healthcare jobs in our state. The final budget last year lessened those cuts, but subsequent deficit projections and cuts have brought additional compensation cuts, which are driving cutbacks in clinics and hospitals across the state.

Jindal’s budget cuts are wiping out good paying jobs across Louisiana. Yes, he is reducing the number of state employees, but Medicaid cuts are costing the state thousands of healthcare jobs each year and the cuts in higher education are shutting down programs, costing hundreds of instruction and support jobs, and sending research dollars out of the state that otherwise would have come here. At the K-12 level, Jindal is trying to push costs down to local school systems and eliminating programs intended to improve the performance of students in the critical early grades.

Compounding the error are recent revelations that outsourcing of state services particularly in the areas of health and social services will actually drive up the cost of operating those programs, and it is clear that Louisiana is merely a prop for Jindal’s political posturing on the national political stage.

Louisiana is historically a low-wage state. The jobs that Jindal’s cuts are forcing in healthcare, higher education and K-12 are not jobs that will make people rich, but they are good jobs that support middle class families and that have a high probability of including benefits packages for the people holding them.

And while Jindal saved 1,300 or so low-wage jobs in Union Parish by subsidizing the purchase of a bankrupt chicken plant, his cuts are forcing far larger losses of better paying jobs in the public and private sectors.

Bobby Jindal is sacrificing those good Louisiana jobs at the altar of his national political ambition.

Coming Friday: “Jindal’s Way: Economic Carnage”

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

KTBS, KLFY contribute of one hour of air time to GOP to attack healthcare reform

KTBS in Shreveport and KLFY in Lafayette will be making huge in-kind contributions to the Republican Party's efforts to kill healthcare reform by airing an all-Republican town hall meeting on healthcare and calling it a public service.

KTBS will carry the program tonight live from Shreveport starting at 8 p.m. KLFY in Lafayette will rebroadcast the program on Thursday afternoon at 4:30 p.m. There are probably other stations involved. I have direct knowledge about these two.

The only panelists taking part in the forum are three Republican congressmen from Louisiana — Charles Boustany, John Fleming and Bill Cassidy. There will be no Democratic involvement in the event.

No Democrat on the panel.

And this is news?

I saw an announcement of the forum on KFLY in Lafayette on Sunday afternoon. I called the news director on Monday morning. Dwight Dugas confirmed that the three panelists were the three Republican members of the Louisiana congressional delegation who are doctors.

I asked him what the news value of such an event would be. He said "to inform the public"

I asked him how this could be considered informing the public about healthcare reform when only one side of the issue would be presented. He said the information would come in the form of questions submitted by the public.

As anyone who has watched the Republican town hall meetings knows, attendance is limited to supporters and questons are screened in advance.

Yet, KLFY and KTBS want the public to believe that this will some how be different.

The Lafayette Parish Democratic Executive Committee has delivered a letter to KLFY calling for the station to either cancel its re-broadcast or to give supporters of healthcare reform an hour of that station's time. The letter is here (PDF).

This is a travesty of journalism even by the low standards of today's market-driven television news.

In a conversation with the station manager of KLFY this morning, I was offered two hours to find a Democratic doctor who would take part in the forum which is being held in Shreveport tonight. I found a doctor who would be happy to debate the other doctors on the subject, but not on such short notice. Besides, he would have had to leave his practice at midday in order to get to Shreveport in time for tonight's event.

As I told the KLFY manager, it is not our responsibility to give their forum the air of responsibility that they did not see fit to confer on it through the bias the premise obviously carries with it.

I believe that if there is no Democratic participation in tonight's forum, then KTBS and any other station carrying the event will have to file an in-kind contribution report with the Federal Elections Commission showing the one-hour of air time they are giving to this obviously partisan event.

Subscribe Now: Feed Icon

D2D Archive

Louisiana Democrat2Democrat