Showing posts with label LSU Hospitals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LSU Hospitals. Show all posts

Monday, January 3, 2011

If Jindal’s Got the Job He Wants, Why Is He Still Fighting Health Care Reform?


Governor Bobby Jindal insists that he is not running for president, that he has the only job he wants — that of being governor of Louisiana.

There is a simple way that the governor could prove that: he could order Attorney General Buddy Caldwell to withdraw Louisiana from the suit challenging the new health care reform law, the Affordable Care Act.

Why? Because the Affordable Care Act is good for what ails Louisiana.

Admitting that might not help Jindal’s standing among national Republicans, but there is no better way to prove his commitment to serving Louisiana than dropping a politicized legal challenge to a law that helps Louisiana families and businesses, the health care provider community, and the State of Louisiana. In fact, under Jindal, state government has moved to take advantage of provisions of the new law.

To understand why this law is good for Louisiana, it is necessary to understand the state of health in Louisiana today. Doing so reveals that the Affordable Care Act goes a long way towards addressing what ails health care in this state (and, also, this country).

The Affordable Care Act addresses key things that ail Louisiana and Louisiana’s health care delivery system. It will not only improve access to care in Louisiana, it will stabilize the finances of the provider community and ensure that the state’s health care dollars (spent primarily through Medicaid) get more bang for the buck.

For Democrats, recognizing the state of health care in Louisiana and understanding how the Act responds to what ails it, reveals the blatantly partisan nature of the attacks on the law by Jindal and others. The sound public policy at the heart of the act reveals the efforts to deny Louisiana citizens, businesses and the provider community the benefits of this Act to be strictly partisan and diametrically opposite of the best interests of the state and its people.

Understanding Louisiana’s health care challenges and how the Act responds to those reveals the opponents of the Act for what they are — partisans who place politics above any consideration for the well being of the people of this state.

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Jindal's Budget Cuts to Kill More Jobs than Drilling Moratorium

All summer long, Louisiana residents were subjected to non-stop lying and yammering by Governor Bobby Jindal and his allies about the potential threat to Louisiana jobs posed by the deep water drilling moratorium. Although the job losses never materialized, the mere thought of them had Jindal & Co. speaking in apocalyptic terms about Louisiana's economic future in the wake of the temporary drilling shutdown.

In contrast to his previous agitation regarding the possibility of job losses, the Governor seems eerily serene as he prepares to unleash new rounds of state budget cuts that will cut services and cost jobs in both the public and private sector.

In a note to supporters last week, Jindal reiterated his opposition to any form of tax increases. He also took credit for all good news in the state and laid blame for any bad news at the feet of others. That's just the way he rolls.

But a funny thing happened while Jindal was on an out-of-state jaunt: some inconvenient facts escaped into public view.

Turns out that the Governor's plan to close Earl K. Long Medical Center in Baton Rouge will cost about 400 people their jobs. That fact came via testimony from the hospital's CEO before the Louisiana Senate Finance Committee. That number is significant on a couple of scores.

First, according to the LSU Health System's 2008 annual report (PDF — the most recent one available), there were 1,266 full-time employees at the hospital. So, about one-third of the people working at the hospital will lose their job as a result of the shut down. Ostensibly the hospital is being closed to save money, but LSU VP for the Health System, Dr. Fred Cerise has pointed out that the shift of services to private hospitals will actually drive up the cost of Medicaid services in the Baton Rouge area due to higher reimbursement rates the hospitals are being promised by the state to take the increased patient loads resulting from the closure.

The other reason that the job loss number is significant is that it is larger than the actual number of jobs affected by the deep water drilling moratorium. The Baton Rouge Area Foundation was selected to administer a $100 million fund created to help those who lost their jobs as a result of the moratorium.

Fewer that 400 workers applied for the funds.

So, this single example of Jindal's focus on dismantling public institutions will have a larger negative impact on jobs than the moratorium he so passionately excoriated, yet his allies have not rented any large arenas to rally the populace against the extermination of these jobs.

More Job Losses Are Coming

House Speaker Jim Tucker and Jindal don't agree on much these days, but they do still appear to share a desire to dismantle much (if not all) of the state's public hospital system now run by LSU. Three hospitals are run out of the Shreveport Health Sciences Center in Shreveport (Shreveport, Huey P. Long in Pineville, and E.A. Conway in Monroe). The rest of the system is run by the LSU Health Sciences Center in New Orleans. The hospitals run there Earl K. Long in Baton Rouge, Bogalusa Medical Center, Leonard Chabert Medical Center in Houma, University Medical Center in Lafayette, Walter O. Moss Regional Medical Center in Lake Charles, the Interim Public Hospital in New Orleans, and Lallie Kemp Regional Medical Center in Independence.

The two systems employ about 13,000 doctors, nurses, aides, orderlies, and staff.

In the minds of Jindal and his Republican legislative allies, just about all of those hospitals and most of those jobs are on the cutting table.

Coming on the heels of the most recent session where Jindal successfully pushed for the privatization of three state mental health hospitals, the people running these hospitals feel threatened, particularly those at the smaller hospitals.

Last Friday, State Rep. John Bel Edwards, Sen. Ben Nevers, and Tangipahoa Parish President Gordon Burgess took part in a meeting at the hospital about the facility's future. The hospital handled more than 100,000 cases last year. Beyond the essential healthcare services it provides to its patients, 39 percent of which did not have health insurance last year, Lallie Kemp (like the other hospitals in the LSU system) is an economic engine in that region.

According to Rep. Edwards, Lallie Kemp has a $90 million annual economic impact on Independence and the surrounding area in the Florida Parishes. In the 2008 annual LSU annual report, the hospital was listed as having 400 full-time employees or their equivalent.

Although Rep. Edwards said he knows of no current plan to close or cut back services at the hospital, he said that the planning for a 35 percent cut in state funding Jindal has ordered all departments to plan for could change that dramatically.

The loss in access to care would be devastating to the people in that region. But those losses could pale in comparison to the economic impact on communities closing of Lallie Kemp or any of the other public hospitals in the LSU systems would have.

Still, Jindal insists that no taxes will be raised and that the state will make do with the revenue base it currently has.

The Medicaid Rebellion

Jindal's initial DHH Secretary Alan Levine confected a plan to bring private insurance companies into manage the Medicaid program and to reduce funding for the program but claim that the quality of care would not diminish. Brazenly branded "Making Medicaid Better" the plan has met with fierce opposition from the provider community (doctors, hospitals, ambulance providers, etc.).

Why would providers object to cutting funding for care to the poor? Because Medicaid (like Medicare) works by paying providers to deliver care. That is, the money for these 'public' health programs goes directly to private providers (some also goes to public providers like the LSU hospitals).

Shrinking funding while extending new hands in the till to manage the care delivered will result in reduced funding for providers. You can do the math. Reduced funding for providers results in fewer providers willing to deliver the services which, in turn,  results in reduced access to care.

The Medicaid program in Louisiana is huge; in excess of $7 billion flows through the program annually, but the vast majority of the money is federal money as Louisiana has one of the most generous federal match ratios in the country due to the fact that we are a poor state and have had strong champions for the program in the Senate.

The Louisiana Hospital Association, fighting proposed budget cuts in 2009, said a $200 million cut in Medicaid funding would cost Louisiana nearly 2,000 healthcare jobs. Although those cuts were staved off at the time, succeeding budget shortfalls have resulted in far more money being cut from Medicaid since that time.

With Jindal's refusal to consider new funding sources and a budget shortfall approaching $2 billion anticipated at the start of the next fiscal year (and with Jindal still not having made good on his pledge to revised the State Constitution to ensure that not all cuts come solely from healthcare and higher education), new cuts in Medicaid are going to result in significant job losses in both the public and private segments of the healthcare delivery system.

Higher Education Remains Targeted

Higher education is the other segment of the state's budgets that are not constitutionally protected. Jindal has been taking heat publicly for his cuts in this area, owing in no small measure for the affection many alums feel for their old schools.

While large segments of our state like to sneer at the 'pointy heads' in academia, higher education has significant economic impact on the communities fortunate enough to have such institutions in their midst. As a native of Eunice, I can tell you that I shudder to think what that city would be like economically today were it not for the presence of the LSU-E campus there.

The University of Louisiana System put together an economic impact fact sheet (PDF) a couple of years ago when Jindal first locked in on his 'no new taxes for any reason' strategy of pursuing his national ambitions.

The economic impact of LSU on the Baton Rouge area is immense and its impact on the entire state through the AgCenter, the LSU Hospital System, and other initiatives is at least as large as the UL system's.

Jindal maintains that the universities are not delivering enough value, that people take too long to graduate, if they do at all. It might do the Governor some good to actually talk to the people who are working their way through college. He would learn about the kind of balancing act they have to do among work, family and school. He might also take a whack at explaining how increasing tuition is going to make those students move through the system faster.

But, as a man with no ties to any higher educational institution in the state, it's all just about numbers to him.

Jobs, Jobs, Jobs

This summer, Jindal was all about jobs — when he wasn't killing oysters or generally making a nuisance of himself (see page 20) during the BP Gulf Gusher. But the jobs he was worried about were the oilfield service jobs of people employed by his biggest political backers — the Bollingers and the Chouests. His concern, one could convincingly argue, was not about the jobs at all, but about the threat Jindal believed the moratorium posed to his benefactors.

Despite the fact that he is the child of public employees, Jindal exhibits a peculiar disdain for their work and their well being. No doubt his judgment on the worth of these workers and services is clouded by his national Republican ambitions which makes tax increases an anathema, a fact that has been compounded by the rise of the Tea Party wing within the Republican Party.

The complicating factor for Jindal is that 2011 is a statewide election year and his national ambitions cannot be advanced if he cannot get re-elected here.

Democrats are not well positioned now, but neither was the national party in 1991 before Bill Clinton challenged George H.W. Bush (or, 'Bush the Intelligent' compared to his son).

People who value higher education are going to have to step up. Dave Treen is dead and it's doubtful whether another intervention at the Mansion can prevent the new author from pushing ahead with his plans to slash programs.

Jindal was elected, in part, by people who believed that he was a problem solver who understood the value of education and knew how to manage healthcare. He's proven that he is none of the above.

The forces of opposition to his policies are firming. It remains to be seen if someone can step forward and give voice to that opposition in a way that either forces Jindal to change his path — or costs him re-election.

Strange things have a way of happening on the way to coronations in a democracy.

Saturday, August 7, 2010

Grand Theft NOLA


In 1985, then Governor Edwin Edwards was indicted and tried on federal charges that he was selling hospital certificates of need to his allies in exchange for money. A hung jury led to a new trial in 1986 in which Edwards and four co-defendants were acquitted.

Suffice it to say that if the thought would have even entered Edwin Edwards' mind to do what Bobby Jindal is doing in New Orleans now with the still-to-be-built Teaching Hospital in New Orleans, grand juries would have already been impaneled and Judge Frank Polozola would be clawing his way back to the bench in anticipation of the indictments and trial.

Looting the Healthcare Infrastructure

What is Jindal doing? He's taking more than $1.2 billion in public money and giving it to a private corporation that will be beyond the control or supervision of the Legislature and the public. The first $800 million or so of the funds were either appropriated by the Legislature or awarded to the state by the federal government through FEMA to replace the former Big Charity Hospital in New Orleans that was flooded in the wake of the federal levee collapse after Hurricane Katrina in 2005.

The remaining $400 million or so will come through financing arranged through LSU which, when we last checked, was the state's land grant university and a public entity.

Killing the state's public hospital system has been a goal of Jindal's since the days when he ran the Department of Health & Hospitals for Governor Mike Foster. He's made considerable progress. Shortly after taking office, he killed plans laid by Governor Kathleen Blanco to build a new state hospital to replace Huey P. Long Medical Center in Pineville.

Last year, Jindal made clear to LSU that if it wanted a replacement hospital for Big Charity in New Orleans, it would have to scuttle Earl K. Long Regional Medical Center in Baton Rouge. Governor Blanco had also started a funding process to rebuild this hospital, but Jindal made clear to LSU's Health Care Vice President Fred Cerise that killing EKL was the price the university would pay to get a hospital in New Orleans. So, Cerise struck a deal with Our Lady of the Lake Regional Medical Center in Baton Rouge to take over the handling of some Medicaid patients and to serve as the home institution for LSU's medical education program in Baton Rouge.

Jindal insisted that the Legislature have no say in the appointments to the New Orleans hospital board, fighting hard in the recent Regular Session Senator Ed Murray's attempt to give the Senate the right to confirm appointments to the governing board.

This past week, Jindal grabbed full control of the project when his majority on the LSU Board of Supervisors overruled LSU System President John Lombardi's choice to chair the governing board and replace her with one of Jindal's biggest contributors, Baton Rouge meat magnate Bobby Yarborough. Jindal had appointed Yarborough to the LSU Board of Supervisors in June, apparently with some role like this already in mind.

Jindal's true intentions became abundantly clear when members of Jindal's staff convened a closed door meeting on Wednesday in New Orleans involving nine of the 11 members of the hospital governing board. Jindal legal counsel Stephen Waguespack described it as a "social meeting" that did not violate the state open meetings law. Waguespack told the Time-Picayune that he was not sure if the open meetings law applies to the new corporation.

Pure and simple, this is a power grab to enable a money grab.

The Jindal MO: Public Dollars to Private Donors

The so-called Ethics Governor™ has a record replete with lavishing public dollars in service of the projects of his biggest contributors. Gary Chouest's project got nearly $30 million. Lev Dawson's sweet potato farm just happens to be next door to a ConAgra plant that Jindal put $30 million of state dollars into. The Shaw Group, which gave the Louisiana Republican Party and the Louisiana Committee for a Republican Majority, a matching set of $50,000 contributions in recent years, got the contract to dredge for Bobby's berms without having to go through a bid process.

Nice rewards that a governor with a compliant Legislature can give. But, as has been clear for quite sometime, Jindal has much higher aspirations than Baton Rouge and to do that, it's going to take a lot more money than he's raised to run for re-election. To do that, he needs another mechanism to draw deeper from the deep pockets of the people who can fund his campaigns.

No, to do that, Jindal needs to do more than a couple of one-off investments in private projects. He needs to create lasting money streams for his supporters — or potential supporters. That business model was perfected under the Bush/Cheney administration. It is crony capitalism.

Jindal's fight to privatize the state's mental health hospitals, in retrospect, was where he showed his hand for what he has in mind for the New Orleans teaching hospital. He wants to be able to distribute lucrative contracts for management and services in a way that is beyond the reach of the Legislature and beyond the review of the public. Jindal said he vetoed HB 1443 by Rep. John Bel Edwards because the "additional steps" of legislative oversight of the privatization process "would hinder" the state's ability to accomplish his goals, which are to distribute the contracts as he sees fit.

Apply that logic to the teaching hospital in New Orleans and what you come up with is Jindal having (and exercising) the power to award contracts for managing and providing services to the hospital built with public dollars without anyone having any ability to review those contracts. Who would do that? The hand-picked board members from LSU? The other board members that Jindal influences or controls?

Jindal is all about monetizing his in-state political power to fuel his national political ambitions.

He intends to take the new hospital in New Orleans behind a wall of secrecy where he can wheel and deal as he sees fit. It will be interesting to see if this hospital, which was supposed to replace Big Charity, will actually provide care to the uninsured, or if they will be shunted elsewhere.


There can be no ethics if there is no transparency — and Jindal has a long record of resisting any and all attempts to bring transparency to the operation of his office.

The theft here is the taking of a public healthcare asset and turning it over to a private corporation so that it can become a profit center, economic engine and political funding machine. The well-being of the citizens who were dependent on Big Charity is nowhere in the Jindal agenda. Jindal's only interest in healthcare is as a political issue. It was a stepping stone for him early in his career. Until the BP Gulf Gusher it was his feeble last leg of credibility on the national scene. Now, it is a vehicle for political alchemy — turning public health into private political profit.

The scale of this power grab is unmatched by anything seen since the days of Huey Long. Unlike Long, Jindal does not pretend to be the least bit interested in throw even collateral benefits to the public as he diligently works to build his funding base upon the wreckage he is creating of Louisiana's public health infrastructure.

No, this is all about Bobby.

The Press Has Been Bamboozled

The mainstream media in this state is bamboozled. Despite Jindal's fierce (and thus far successful) efforts to preserve a wall of secrecy around his office, he still gets the benefit of the doubt on matters like does the open meetings law apply to the new hospital board.

There can be no ethics if there is no transparency. Jindal will not allow transparency. His claims of ethical conduct rest solely on his claims of ethical conduct.

But there is a strain of deception that is becoming more clear every day and it has emerged from his dealings with the Gulf Gusher. We know that he's lied about the origin of the berm plan. He's lied about the terms of the government permit to dredge for the berms. We also know that he's lied about the impact of the deep water drilling moratorium on the state's economy.

All these fresh lies and the press continues to defer to him. At what point do they allow themselves to engage in critical thinking again and begin to examine Jindal's maneuvers with a critical eye?

Probably not until he's hit the national campaign trail. At which point, the next governor will be left cleaning up his mess. Sounds exactly like the task that President Obama assumed after his predecessor's adventures in crony capitalism nearly wrecked the country.

Thursday, June 24, 2010

The Kept Speaker: Fiscal conservatives got rolled by the Governor, but Jim Tucker did just fine


When Governor Bobby Jindal swooped into Baton Rouge last Friday to back the Senate version of the state's two budgets (the current fiscal year and the upcoming fiscal year), House Speaker Jim Tucker bemoaned the fact that the Governor had backed two budgets that did not reflect the values of fiscal conservatives.

It's a view Tucker has repeated on a number of occasions since the session ended. It was a frustrating end to the session for Tucker, who spent most of his time frustrating friends and foes alike. The trouble started with his ham-handed handling of the election of Joel Robideaux of Lafayette to the position of Speaker Pro Tempe. Tucker dished out some tough love to people who he said had broken commitments made to him on the vote. A tinge of bitterness stayed in the air for the rest of the session.

But, fate stepped in during April when Governor Bobby Jindal decided to relocated to Plaquemines Parish to lead the state's response to the BP Gulf Gusher. That cat being away gave Tucker room to play and, man, did he have a run.

Tucker took control of the budget process. He doggedly pursued the long-cherished dream of Louisiana conservatives of closing large swaths if not all of the LSU Hospital system (formerly the Charity Hospital System. He chased his plan to consolidate all of the higher education boards in the state only to find that his handling of the Robideaux election and aftermath would deny him success on this score.

He was steadfast in his position on how the state could borrow from and repay money from the so-called Rainy Day Fund. He refused to recognize the final estimate of the state's economists on the size of the hole in the current year budget, thereby setting the stage for a climactic showdown with the Senate and his nemesis Senate President Joel Chaisson II.

All the while, Tucker and his favorite Democratic Representative Jim Fannin went to the four-corners offense on the budget, holding onto to it as long as they possibly could. When the House approved HB-1 with just two weeks left in the session, the bill reflected Tucker's vision of the future of state government.

It pretty much scared the hell out of everyone in the Senate and anyone with a conscience. At a time when the state is giving more than $7 billion in tax breaks to businesses and the well-heeled, Tucker's budget would have shut down four or more LSU Hospitals, forced the closure of several state college campuses, and made yet another round of deep cuts in Medicaid. Total state layoffs including the hospital closings, the campus closings and the other reductions in state payrolls could have reached 10,000. That number does not even address the loss in healthcare jobs in the private sector resulting from the Medicaid cuts.

At a time when Jindal and his allies were running around the state and in federal courtrooms predicting economic Armageddon over the temporary loss of about 3,000 to 5,000 deep water drilling and support jobs, hurling that number of state workers out of their jobs at the same time created something of an appearance issue that even the Governor could not ignore.

Tucker was unfazed. Maybe he knew the drilling job numbers were a sham or maybe he just does not care about the impact of massive job losses on the state economy; either way, Tucker pushed on.

Then Jindal flew in and took away all of Tucker's fun. The Speaker ended up voting against the budget, as did group of other House members. In the end, Tucker found out that Speakers only have power so long as the Governor lets them have it, or if the Governor is preoccupied with other matters.

It is testimony to just how draconian Tucker's budget was that eliminating 3,000 state jobs, cutting $25 million from Medicaid reimbursements, $25 million in cuts for higher education, and guts funding for the arts was considered something of a victory.

Whatever relief might exist could well be short-lived if state revenues continue their downward trend, wrecking the assumptions on which the budget was built. But, if needed, those cuts will be made by the Jindal administration.

On the Sunday, the second-to-last day of the session, Tucker got some help cushioning the blow of his Wiley Coyote-like defeat on the budget. He won legislative approval to have the swank apartment in the Pentagon Barracks that had previously been the realm of the Lieutenant Governor designated as the quarters of the Speaker of the House.

That apartment had been extensively remodeled by Mitch Landrieu when he was Lieutenant Governor. Landrieu spent about $1 million in taxpayer money on the renovation and that drew howls from fiscal conservatives.

So, to the Speaker go those spoils. For Tucker, now a man with a considerable list of foes in the Capitol and the House, the challenge will be to keep that job title that brings the perk heading into the final year of his term.

The perk is his — if he can remain Speaker.

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Jindal's Hack Attacks


Alan Levine was billed as the "Department of Health and Hospitals Secretary" when he appeared at the Baton Rouge Press Club on Monday. But as anyone who caught his presentation (PDF) on the impact of healthcare reform on Louisiana immediately grasped, the cabinet secretary title is a cover for Levine's true role as Jindal's most ardent partisan hack.

From attacking healthcare reform to barring DHH employees from talking to legislators about policy to calling for investigations to try to stifle opposition to privatization, Alan Levine is the tip of the spear on the governor's effort to use healthcare policy to shrink state government and give more power (and money) to private contractors.

Levine is continuing the work that Jindal started as Mike Foster's DHH secretary just over a decade ago. The difference is that Levine actually knows something about healthcare policy (if Jindal knows anything about it, he learned it after he left DHH) and has not (at least not yet) displayed the kind of unbridled political ambition that Jindal personifies.

Still, Levine came to the job after finding his place in Florida politics in Jeb Bush's second administration. He came to Louisiana after taking over a struggling hospital system for Bush, privatized much of it (some of it using no-bid contracts) and rode that success to his job with Jindal.

Man On A Mission

Levine came to Louisiana in 2008 on a mission. That mission was to radically restructure the delivery of healthcare in Louisiana in a way that would help propel Jindal's Republican political ambitions.

First on the agenda was a complete makeover of Medicaid, the jointly funded healthcare program that provides care to women, children and the disabled. Levine had run a pilot program in Florida that set up a managed care approach to running Medicaid there. The idea was to limit spending by restricting access to care. The restriction would come through the management of care by third-party entities who had a similar role in the scheme to that of HMOs. There was a fixed pool of money. The managed care provider would negotiate a package deal with providers to provide care for Medicaid patients. The managed care provider would get paid out of the existing pool of funds.

It is classic conservative Republican approach to policy: make the dollars go further by cutting back on the amount of services delivered and make some company rich in the process.

Levine hit the ground running in Louisiana, but there were complications with the calendar. Jindal and Levine wanted to get a Medicaid waiver approved by the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) while the Bush administration was still in office. This should not have been an issue seeing as Jindal had served in that administration and Levine had served in the administration of the President's brother who was the governor of Florida.

There were complications.

The first factor was that the move could not begin until the new state budget for Fiscal Year 2008-2009 was in place. Louisiana fiscal years begin on July 1. It took Levine a couple of months to organize an advisory committee whose purpose was ostensibly to provide input on the development of a Medicaid waiver request.

The panel was barely in place when the first of what has become a seemingly unending series of Medicaid budget shortfalls was discovered in late September of 2008. Shortly after that happened, Levine christened his Medicaid waiver "Louisiana Health First" and the generally genial discussions with the so-called advisory panel continued.

Things blew up when Jindal and Levine announced the plan fully-formed in November 2008 and committed to filing with with CMS in the waning days of the Bush administration. Members of the advisory committee went public with criticism of Levine for a lack of transparency in the process they were allegedly supposed to be participants in. It certainly appeared to the members of that group that they had been used by Levine to provide a patina of legitimacy to a plan that Levine had developed without their input or knowledge.

It was two days before Christmas, 2008, before Levine got his waiver request to CMS — the Legislature had to sign off on it and there were questions. By this time, all the DC Bushies were either too busy packing or had already left the nation's capital seeking new opportunities in what was no longer a Republican town.

Louisiana Health First came to naught, though it did poison Levine's credibility among Medicaid providers — a distrust that informs his relations with them today.

Privatization

The first big challenge for the Jindal administration on the privatization front was the question of what to do with Big Charity Hospital in New Orleans, which had been rendered useless by the post-Katrina flooding.

Governor Kathleen Blanco had somehow convinced a recalcitrant Louisiana Legislature to approve planning dollars for three new LSU hospitals in the wake of the storms of 2005 — Big Charity, Earl K. Long Medical Center in Baton Rouge, and Huey P. Long Medical Center in Pineville.

The initial impulse of the administration was to scrap all three hospitals, but the pressure to build a new hospital in New Orleans was too important to the post-Katrina recovery narrative for Jindal to ignore. Combined with a commitment from the Veterans Administration to build a new hospital in New Orleans, the project constitutes a nearly $2 billion investment in post-Katrina New Orleans.

Levine became the point man on what became very clearly a quid pro quo between the administration and LSU. The deal came down to this: LSU could get a hospital in New Orleans but it could not get a hospital in Baton Rouge, too. Sort of a "nice hospital you've got there, LSU. It would be a shame if anything happened to it." The new Pineville hospital was dead on arrival.

In the dance that ensued, LSU ended up negotiating a deal with Our Lady of the Lake Regional Medical Center thereby enabling the closure of Earl K. Long. Some of the capacity served by that hospital will be replaced by a large outpatient clinic near Earl K. Long. Our Lady of the Lake agreed to take some of the Medicaid patient load (at a higher-than-average reimbursement rate) and to become home for LSU's medical training program in Baton Rouge. They'll also get a Tier 1 trauma center, courtesy of the state.

Cerise told the Times-Picayune after the deal was struck that the cost of shifting care from Earl K. Long to OLOL will actually drive up Medicaid costs in the Baton Rouge area. So, this example shows that cost savings is not the intent of the Jindal/Levine privatization effort. Instead, the goal is to dismantle public healthcare infrastructure ranging from public hospitals in the LSU hospital system to the state's three mental health hospitals in Mandeville, Pineville and Jackson.

This clearly is privatization for privatization's sake. It will have two immediate impacts. First, it will remove hundreds (ultimately thousands if carried to its end) of workers from the state payroll. Second, it will create lucrative contracting opportunities for private sector firms who move in to operate the remaining operations which is the plan for the mental health hospitals.

The question of the quality of care given to patients was raised in one legislative hearing by a family member of a resident in one of the state mental health institutions. It is apparently not relevant to Jindal and Levine as it is not quantifiable as a budget item.

Jackson: A Deal Too Far

Levine's effort to privatize the state's mental health hospitals has sparked a surprising bi-partisan rebellion in the Legislature against the move. The plan to privatize the East Louisiana State Hospital at Jackson was apparently the deal too far.

East, as it is known, is located in East Feliciana Parish. The move to privatize jeopardizes hundreds of jobs in that rural parish and that brought employees and the business community together in opposition to the plan. It led to a confrontation in the Legislature where the normally Jindal-friendly House voted to require legislative oversight of the privatization process.

Levine, apparently seeking to crush the rebellion at ground zero, called on the inspector general to review employment records at the three facilities — East, Central Louisiana State Hospital in Pineville and Southeast Louisiana Hospital at Mandeville — to check what he suggested were abuses of the family leave policies at the facilities.

Attacking Healthcare Reform

Jindal and Levine were early critics of President Obama's attempts to reform the nation's healthcare delivery system, and they have not relented since 2009.

Levine was called to Washington by congressional Republicans to deliver highly partisan attacks on the Democratic initiative dating to its infancy. No matter the shape of the reform at any given time during the arduous legislative journey to becoming law, Levine could be counted on to take up the Republican talking points against the plan.

Once the bill became law in April, Levine became the in-state point man of Republican efforts to fight the implementation of the law.

Levine testified before the Louisiana House Insurance Committee on April 20 in support of Representative Kirk Talbot's constitutional amendment to have the state nullify the provisions of the Affordable Care Act. Levine, like Talbot, put the fight within the context of states' rights.

Well, any excuse would do, wouldn't it.

In late May, when the non-partisan Kaiser Family Foundation published a state-by-state assessment of the impact of the Affordable Care Act on extending coverage to low-wage individuals and families, Levine lashed out with a partisan harangue that focused only on the cost side of the law and the analysis. Nowhere in his response could Levine bring himself to acknowledge any benefit being derived —economic, community, social or otherwise — that would result from extending healthcare coverage to a broad swath of Louisiana's large number of uninsured residents.

That inability to acknowledge any positive aspect in a policy or program being opposed is the trademark of an ideologue.

And it was Levine the ideologue who took the podium at the Baton Rouge Press Club on Monday and delivered a presentation that is so blatantly political that it raises questions regarding how public funding can be used to produce such a clearly political document (PDF).

Lies, Damned Lies, and Levine's Statistics

Like Jindal, the only thing that has value in Levine's view of healthcare is money. If a program costs dollars, then it must be bad.

How else can one assess a 32-page presentation on a piece of landmark social legislation that never mentions any social benefit but focuses exclusively on the cost of the program — and inflates those costs to cast the legislation in the worst possible light?

Levine's intent is to show as large dollar costs to the state as he can possibly imagine. He projects 13 years out to come up with a projected increased cost to the state of $7 billion, and he has to use a premise of private sector employers dropping coverage for their workers and dumping them on the Medicaid rolls to get there.

Like Jindal, Levine assumes that state revenues will never increase again. Therefore, the prospect of the state actually having the revenue to pay for he increased costs that the program will actually bring are beyond his capability of imagining. One is left to assume that the idea of state revenues increasing would be considered a nightmare scenario in the world of Jindal/Levine.

Levine completely ignores the reality that the current system of employer based healthcare is not sustainable without reform. The Affordable Care Act maintains private sector insurance, imposes some requirements on companies and requires individuals to buy coverage. It provides tax credits to businesses to provide coverage and it provides subsidies to individuals and families to enable them to afford coverage. It will improve access to care for nearly all Louisiana residents, which will go far to address our chronic disease problems. It will inject billions of dollars into the care provider community, putting hospitals, clinics and individual providers on better financial footing.

Levine cannot bring himself to mention — much less admit — any of this.

This kind of distorted take on healthcare reform could be expected from the kind of partisan hack that Levine clearly is. But, he should stop hiding behind his title as cabinet secretary in his pursuit of his partisan agenda. Alan Levine is a suitable political operative for Bobby Jindal, but he is abusing his office as secretary of the Department of Health and Hospitals at this critical juncture in our state's history.

Serving in that capacity involves a public trust. Levine's loyalty should be to his oath and to the public. It is clear that his loyalty is to Jindal and his ideology.

If he had any decency, he'd resign.

Again, if he had any decency.

Sunday, May 30, 2010

The Three Pinnochioes of Louisiana Healthcare


The ability to sell a lie — particularly when it affects public policy — depends in large measure on the ability of those pushing the lie to dominate the conversation, to keep selling their particular narrative until it verges on becoming the accepted truth.

The Kaiser Family Foundation, a non-partisan organization that has focused on healthcare policy, issued a report on Wednesday that looks at the impact of the expansion of Medicaid eligibility contained in the recently enacted healthcare reform legislation. In so doing, the numbers demolished the core lie of the Jindal administration's plan to close the public hospitals operated by LSU — that the loss of disproportionate share dollars will make the hospitals fiscally unsustainable. Here's the Kaiser press release. Here's the executive summary (PDF). Here's the full report (PDF).

The lie being pushed by Jindal, DHH Secretary Alan Levine and Speaker Jim Tucker — The Three Pinnochioes — is that the loss of a few hundred million dollars of disproportionate share dollars will doom the hospitals. What they don't want people to know — and what the Kaiser report makes clear — is that this expansion of Medicaid contained in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) will bring Billions of new healthcare dollars into the state that will more than offset the loss of that much smaller figure.

The report points out that this infusion of federal dollars will begin in 2014 with the federal government picking up the tab for the entire expansion in year one, falling to 95.6% of the cost of the expansion over the ensuring five years (Table 1, on page 12 in the full report).

In all, expansion of Medicaid eligibility could bring a minimum of $7.2 billion in new healthcare dollars into Louisiana, reducing the percentage of uninsured Louisiana residents living just above the poverty level by half. And, that's if the state does a poor job of reaching out to those currently uninsured to make them aware of the opportunity to gain coverage. If the state does a more aggressive outreach program, 74.8% of those now uninsured would have coverage.

In a hastily drawn up response to the Kaiser report, Levine actually agreed with the numbers. He and his boss Jindal just don't want to see it happen.

As the Kaiser report points out, "Medicaid is voluntary, states may choose to not to participate and thereby forego the federal Medicaid funding to which participating states are entitled. States that elect not to implement these new requirements in effect would be making the choice not to participate." (Page 7, Executive Summary)

Opting out is the route that The Three Pinnochioes plan to take, turning their back on billions of dollars in federal healthcare dollars, and opening the path for them to close the LSU hospitals. The only problem is that those dollars are dollars are bound for providers — doctors, hospitals, and clinics — who take Medicaid patients. Relations between the Jindal administration and the provider community are already strained after three years of budget cuts that resulted in reduced reimbursements rates.

Denying providers billions of dollars to cover what is otherwise uncompensated care would be signing a death warrant for many community hospitals who deliver much of the Medicaid. If The Three Pinnochioes succeed in their effort to kill the LSU hospitals, those community hospitals would be expected to pick up the patient load now handled by the LSU system, particularly those without any ability to pay.

The result will be a fiscal calamity for community hospitals and a public health  emergency for the state.

It's the Ideology, Stupid!

In the world of The Three Pinnochioes, this has never been a healthcare issue. This is an ideological issue. They don't believe that the state should operate any hospitals and are committed to closing them. The notion of what happens to the patients is not something that they are particularly concerned about. Never has been.

Ideological rigidity leads to the same answer over and over, regardless of the facts.  The Three Pinnochioes demonstrate this with their unbridled desire to kill the LSU hospitals. Any excuse will do.

The state's budget problems (which they largely created with the repeal of the income tax portions of the Stelly Plan) were the first excuse. Now with the potential for a surge of federal healthcare dollars into the state, they say that's their excuse for needing to kill those hospitals because the money is just not flowing into the the right pots.

In their ideologically driven quest to kill the LSU hospitals, The Three Pinnochioes threaten wrecking the entire healthcare system in this state. The initial impact might be on care for the poor, but it will ultimately accelerate the crisis that is putting health insurance beyond the reach of working families.

In a state where the percentage of working age adults without health insurance is high and climbing, opting out of the Medicaid portion of the ACA would leave Louisiana healthcare costs locked into the death spiral driven by the shifting of the cost of providing care for the uninsured onto the backs of those with coverage. This is the core of the national healthcare crisis. It is driving the cost of health insurance through the roof. A decision to opt out of the Medicaid portion would be the equivalent of smashing the pedal to the metal and heading over the cliff.

But, the cliff is precisely where Jindal wants to see this go for his own political reasons. He's directed Attorney General Buddy Caldwell to file suit challenging the legality of the ACA. He yanked the Department of Insurance back from participating in the new high risk pool for adults denied coverage over pre-existing conditions (a temporary program that will last until 2014 when the pre-existing condition exclusion for adults is outlawed). Refusing to participate in the Medicaid portion of the program would be the next step.

Levine's statement on Wednesday was the tip that this is what's coming.

Jindal's Obsession

Bobby Jindal has wanted to close the state's public hospitals (formerly known as the Charity System) since the days when he was Mike Foster's DHH Secretary. Now Jindal and his DHH Secretary Alan Levine are trying to privatize the operation of the state's three mental health hospitals that has stirred up a hornet's nest of opposition from Democrats and Republicans in those communities, but particularly in the Felicianas around East Louisiana Mental Health hospital in Jackson.

Jindal and Levine made striking a deal to close Earl K. Long Medical Center in Baton Rouge and transfer some of those patient services to Our Lady of the Lake Medical Center one condition of their support for building a new teaching hospital in New Orleans. LSU also had to give up control of that new hospital as part of the deal.

Two down, eight to go. (Note: LSU Health Sciences Center in Shreveport runs the LSU hospitals in that city, Pineville and Monroe.)

The push to close what are now the LSU hospitals will come in the 2011 session in the fight over the 2012 budget. It will be an election year and this will be one of the defining issues coming out of that session and in the election that follows.

That fight might be put off that fight until next year, if the House and Senate can reach a deal on this year's budget. The version of HB-1 approved by the House Appropriations Committee last week will cut $68 million from LSU's hospitals and that will force the closure of some facilities.

House Speaker Jim Tucker, who led the charge to pry LSU's control away from the New Orleans teaching hospital, laid bare the outlines of the game plan during to kill the rest of the system during a May 10 appearance at the Baton Rouge Press Club:
Tucker said national health care changes are going to cost Louisiana more money in the long run. It is being financed partially by diversion of funds from uninsured care which are used to operate the state’s public hospitals, he said. That’s going to prompt a major decision affecting the future of the hospitals, he said.

“What’s interesting about it, it’s taken a Democratic president to in all likelihood get Louisiana out of the hospital business,” said Tucker.
The care for the uninsured that Tucker mentioned will not be needed because ACA is going to provide coverage to most of those who are now uninsured. The issue becomes where will those people go for treatment and care?

Louisiana residents living just above the poverty line are those most likely to be affected by untreated chronic disease. They don't have insurance and so they avoid going to doctors unless and until symptoms get too bad to ignore. Many of those people go to emergency rooms at LSU hospitals for care when things reach that stage.

In 2008, the most recent year available, the LSU hospitals in the southern part of the state (operated by LSU Health Care Services Division) treated a patient population of just over 400,000. There were just under 30,000 hospital admissions, resulting in 144,000 inpatient days. Just over 3,000 psychiatric admissions, resulting in 38,000 psychiatric inpatient days. There were 7,226 full time employees or equivalents at those seven hospitals.

LSU Health Sciences in Shreveport, which operates hospitals in three cities, handled 31,000 admissions; 110,000 emergency room encounters; nearly 600,000 outpatient clinic visits. 41% of their patients are Medicaid patients; 26% are 'free care.' There are 6,200 employees in the hospitals run by this system.

And these patients will go where for care? Community hospitals can't handle this load and, because of Medicaid reimbursement cuts made by The Three Pinnochioes, they would probably resist state efforts to force these patients on them.

In Baton Rouge, it is instructive that DHH will pay Our Lady of the Lake a higher Medicaid reimbursement rate than it will other hospitals in that region in return for agreeing to take on some of the Earl K. Long patient load. Administrators at other hospitals closer to the local patient base of Earl K. Long are worried that they will get stuck with a larger percentage of the patient load but not get paid as much to care for those patients as OLOL will. At least two hospitals (Baton Rouge General and Lane Memorial Hospital in Zachary) believe the deal with OLOL threatens their financial viability if large numbers of former Earl K. Long patients take the shortest routes to healthcare.

So, the cost of delivering Medicaid in the Baton Rouge area will actually go up as a result of the closure of Earl K. Long. But, isn't Medicaid causing the state's budget crisis? Isn't that rising cost going to be the reason The Three Pinnochioes cite when they move to abstain from participation in the expansion of the Medicaid program?

Yes, but with ideologically driven decision-making, any excuse will do.

The Growing Bi-Partisan Backlash

There has been a bi-partisan uprising in the normally conservative House of Representatives against The Three Pinnochioes plan to privatize the state's three mental health hospitals. It has dawned on the people in the Felicianas that those facilities have jobs attached to them as well as providing care for those with mental disabilities, including criminals.

The facts got loose out there and the locals are no longer buying the Jindal spin.

The push to have legislative review of all state professional service contracts is further evidence that the days of the Legislature's rolling over at Jindal's command might be ending ("might be" because these bills have not yet passed both houses and face a probable Jindal veto).

LSU is not in a position to fight the hospital closures directly. They've got too much riding on the teaching hospital in New Orleans and other state funding needs. However, the private sector provider community can — and, really, must — push both for participation in the Medicaid expansion and to fight the closure of the LSU hospitals. The reason is simple: their existence depends on it.

The Kaiser report shows just how much ACA's expansion of Medicaid could mean to them AND how little it would cost the state to take part in that program — $300 to $500 million in state match over a five year period! (Pages 10 and 11 of the Kaiser Executive Summary PDF.)

The Governor has been spending most of his time on the coast, away from the Capitol. The Speaker has been his time in the Capitol and his presence has had about as strong a negative effect as Jindal's absence.

Levine, a former political candidate in Florida who still speaks at Republican candidate workshops here, has proven tone deaf in dealing with the Legislature. He and his aides say legislators are "injecting politics" into the budget process by calling for a review of privatization contracts, yet can only focus on the cost benefits when discussing the proposed moves — as if healthcare is only about money and not about care for people in need. Like the governor he serves, Levine can't see beyond the numbers at the people behind them, nor can he see beyond his ideological blinders.

The public, like legislators, is catching on, along with legislators. With bigger budget holes yet to fill and and opportunity to get federal relief for the most pressing human needs in the state, The Three Pinnochioes appear trapped by their ideology, unable to respond to changing circumstances.

A collision is coming and The Three Pinnochioes seem particularly ill-prepared to handle it.

Subscribe Now: Feed Icon

D2D Archive

Louisiana Democrat2Democrat